Skip to main content

Rise in Auto Theft: How It Impacts Your Car Insurance in 2025

By June 13, 2025Insurance
Home Insurance Quote - Young Couple With Little Boy Son Goes to Their New Car Standing on the New Home Yard Inside Car View

📱 Rise in Auto Theft: How It Impacts Your Car Insurance in 2025

In 2025, auto theft is surging across the U.S., and it’s having a noticeable impact on car insurance premiums, policy renewals, and even vehicle availability. Whether you’re shopping for a new car or renewing your policy, here’s what you need to know.

🚗 The Trend: Auto Thefts Are on the Rise

According to recent industry data, vehicle thefts are up significantly compared to previous years. Thieves are increasingly targeting:

  • Certain makes and models known to be easier to steal

  • Push-to-start vehicles that lack immobilizer technology

  • High-end SUVs and trucks with valuable parts

Popular theft targets in 2024 included Kia, Hyundai, Dodge Charger, and Chevy Silverado. And organized theft rings are using sophisticated tools—sometimes even cloning key fobs—to quickly steal vehicles from driveways, parking lots, and public streets.

💰 Insurance Impact: Why It’s Costing Drivers More

As theft losses mount, insurers are adjusting:

  • Higher premiums in ZIP codes with high theft rates

  • Increased comprehensive deductibles for theft-prone vehicles

  • Tighter underwriting or coverage restrictions for high-risk models

In some cases, insurers may even decline to offer coverage on certain models unless additional anti-theft devices are installed.

🛡️ What You Can Do as a Car Owner

  1. Install Theft Deterrents
    Steering wheel locks, GPS tracking devices, alarm systems, and kill switches can help prevent theft and may earn insurance discounts.

  2. Check Your Comprehensive Coverage
    Theft is covered under comprehensive insurance—not liability or collision. Make sure your policy includes it and that your deductible makes sense.

  3. Ask Your Agent About Risk Factors
    Your ZIP code, vehicle model, and parking situation can all affect your rate. Ask your agent for recommendations on reducing your risk profile.

  4. Take Precautions Daily

    • Always lock your car, even in your driveway

    • Don’t leave keys, key fobs, or valuables inside

    • Park in well-lit or secured areas when possible

🔍 Shopping Tip: Be Cautious When Buying Used

Due to the theft surge, some stolen vehicles are showing up on the used market with altered VINs. Always:

  • Get a full vehicle history report

  • Buy from reputable dealers

  • Look for signs of tampering or repainting


📝 Final Word

Auto theft isn’t just a headline—it’s influencing how much you pay for insurance and how your vehicle is protected. The best defense is being informed and proactive. If you’re unsure whether your current policy protects you adequately, reach out to your insurance agent for a coverage review.

Need help understanding your coverage? Empire Insurance Brokers is here to help you stay protected on the road.